Can a citizen or political leader compel a constitutional body like the Election Commission of India to answer a list of formal questions under oath? The Supreme Court of India is now set to decide this very question.
A three-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant has agreed to examine the maintainability of an application filed by Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi and ten other opposition leaders. The application seeks permission to serve 48 written questions, known in legal terms as interrogatories, directly on the Election Commission of India (ECI).
The court has scheduled the matter for hearing on December 9 after the ECI files its formal objections.
What Are Interrogatories Under Indian Law?
In standard civil court proceedings, lawsuits often depend on documents and facts known only to one side. To prevent surprises at trial and narrow down the real issues, procedural law provides a tool called interrogatories.
An interrogatory is a formal, numbered set of written questions sent by one party to an opposing party during a court case. The receiving party is legally required to answer these questions under oath in the form of an affidavit. Under the Code of Civil Procedure (Order XI) and the Supreme Court Rules, 2013, interrogatories help extract clear admissions and discover relevant facts before final arguments begin.
While interrogatories are routine in commercial and property disputes, directing them at high-ranking constitutional authorities—such as the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners—is exceptionally rare.
The Core Dispute: Allegations Over Voter Roll Revisions
The controversy arises from petitions challenging the ongoing nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Rahul Gandhi and other opposition leaders have alleged large-scale irregular deletions of genuine voters from draft and final lists.
A primary contention raised by the petitioners is whether the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) exercised administrative powers unilaterally. They argue that crucial decisions were taken without the formal concurrence or knowledge of the other two Election Commissioners.
In response, the ECI filed counter-affidavits affirmed by a Deputy Election Commissioner, maintaining that all decisions regarding the nationwide revision were made unanimously by the full three-member commission. However, the petitioners argue that these responses are mere broad assertions. They point out that the ECI failed to provide specific file numbers, dates, or formal meeting minutes to demonstrate collective decision-making.
The petitioners also highlighted an August 2025 response under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, in which commission officials had stated that no decision had been taken to begin a nationwide Special Intensive Revision.
What Do the 48 Questions Ask For?
To settle the factual contradictions, Gandhi and his co-petitioners filed the application under Order V Rule 1, Order XXXVIII Rule 11(9), and Order LV Rule 6 of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013. They demand sworn affidavits personally signed by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Dr. Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Dr. Vivek Joshi.
The 48 questions span ten broad operational areas, including:
- Internal Dissents: Whether Election Commissioners Dr. Sandhu and Dr. Joshi ever recorded written objections or dissenting notes between February 2025 and October 2026 regarding the revision process, digital systems, or court filings.
- IT Security and Private Access: Whether private vendors or technical contractors were given direct editing access to the voter database, and whether an independent access audit proposed within the commission was carried out.
- Bulk Deletions: Clarification on whether names were purged in bulk without specific statutory orders passed by designated Electoral Registration Officers.
- Informal Approvals: State-level deletion data and whether urgent administrative sanctions were issued through informal channels like personal emails or messaging apps.
- Claims of Privilege: A requirement that if the ECI claims official secrecy or legal privilege over any internal file, it must specify the exact legal grounds for each withheld record.
The ECI’s Stance: Serious Objections to the Process
During the brief hearing, Senior Advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the Election Commission, indicated strong resistance to the application. Salve informed the bench that the poll body has serious reservations about the procedure being adopted, arguing that it causes serious prejudice to the commission’s functioning.
Representing Gandhi, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal urged the court to consider the questions to uncover the true factual basis of the administrative actions. Chief Justice Surya Kant observed that the poll panel has every right to place its formal objections on record before the court takes a final view.
“Whatever it is, you may file your reply. You can raise your objections. We will examine the interrogatories issue and then take a call,” the bench observed, which also comprises Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana.
The Precedent: Technology and Exclusive Knowledge
To justify using interrogatories against a constitutional body, the petitioners relied on the Supreme Court’s landmark Constitution Bench ruling in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India.
In that case, the top court recognized that when a constitutional challenge involves complex technical systems or centralized digital records, critical operational facts often lie exclusively within the knowledge of the administering state authority. The petitioners argue that when sworn official replies remain ambiguous about technological handling and database access, judicial process allows the court to mandate direct, sworn answers to targeted questions.
Why This Matters For You
The electoral roll forms the very foundation of India’s representative democracy. If genuine voters are unlawfully removed, the right to vote guaranteed under the constitutional framework is undermined.
From a legal perspective, this case tests the boundaries of judicial oversight. The Supreme Court must now balance two crucial principles: ensuring transparency and accountability in election administration on the one hand, and protecting constitutional institutions from procedural harassment or trial-by-questionnaire on the other. How the court rules on December 9 will establish an important precedent on how deeply courts can probe internal administrative deliberations of independent public authorities.
Story reported by Barandbench. This article is BareLaw’s independent explanation and analysis.
📲 Get every BareLaw story on Telegram — simple legal news, 5 times a day, free: t.me/barelaw